"Homicide: Life on the Street" The Subway (TV Episode 1997) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
11 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
"Back Stage"Look at the Trials and Tribulations of Making the Finest Episode of The Greatest Cop Series Ever!!
redryan642 October 2007
Warning: Spoilers
When one has watched a series such as "HOMICIDE:Life On The Street" for any time you become a sort of "spoiled" viewer. What?, you say. Spoiled, how? Any series such as "HOMICIDE"(and off hand, I sure can't think of any others in their league!)that has been so consistently good, far above the standard of most anyone else, Cop Show or not, gets to a point where they are expected to do it all the time. They are,in essence, taken for granted.

So, what about what happens even the Production Team of "HOMICIDE" brings us a truly different Episode. Different in that it hits the telling of a Criminal Homicide Investigation from a hereto for untried angle.

OUR STORY: During the morning AM Rush Hours, passenger of one of the Baltimore Subway Trains, John Lange(Vincent D'Onofrio) falls, or is pushed off of the platform, and was caught between the moving train and the concrete side wall.

The victim is pinned in place, unable to move. His body has been hideously twisted and contorted, nearly severing his spinal cord in two. He remains conscious and aware of his surroundings. He reports having no sensations of the legs nor the lower extremities.

The incident is relayed by the Uniformed Patrol Division Police in the field to the Baltimore Police Department, Homicide Unit. As an occurrence of undetermined cause, the Detective Division will make an in depth Follow-Up Investigation to the original responding Beat Car's Initial Report.

The Case gets assigned to the team of Det. Frank Pembleton (Andre Braugher) and Tim Bayliss (Kyle Secor). The no-nonsense, business-like, highly professional Pair gets right on it, going directly to the Crime Scene, to canvass, search for witnesses, identify any Physical Evidence, all to ascertain if the incident is a terrible accident, or a Crime, perpetrated by one of the teaming thousands of commuters who pass that way every day.

But this time there is one thing missing from most of the cases that the Dicks from their Unit handle, but is present here.

Det. Frank Pembleton, the Veteran Detective of the pair has always been extremely serious about his having a role as an advocate for the deceased. This is a role that is very difficult to assume, but once gotten into, what was commonplace, would be out of the ordinary and difficult. What they had in this case to mark it as unusual was a living, breathing and awake victim.

And once the Investigation finds the incident is determined to be the doings of an intentionally harmful perpetrator, and not a tragic accident, the Case takes on a whole different meaning.

Because the efforts of moving the train is such a massive task, requiring relocation of heavy equipment and the displacement of so many people on their daily trip Downtown to work, the process is very slow, very slow. As it turns out, it's up to Det. Pembleton to be the communicator with Victim. And it is here that Frank finds possibly the most difficult assignment of his career.

The Paramedics on the scene and their Medical counterparts at the Hospital Trauma Unit have relayed the information that as soon as the Train Car is moved, freeing up Mr. John Lange's legs and lower extremities, he will die. Ironically it is the very TYrain which has his body pinned against the wall, is the one thing causing him to cling to life.

What really gets to Pembleton is having to lie to the Victim, a sham that is detestable to the Police Veteran. After all, being an advocate and champion for those who cannot speak is tough. But now, he must go on in a conspiracy of falsehood in order to render the removal/"rescue" operations smooth.

Being professionals and remaining as uninvolved as possible, Detectives Pembleton and Bayliss go along with the deception. As the dead body of John Lange is removed from the scene, his Wife (or significant other Lady Friend), who has been unreachable all day, jogs right past the scene, oblivious to the occurrence.

"The Subway" Episode did just about the impossible. It took the already high level of programing of "HOMICIDE:Life On The Street" and extended it even higher. It was such a superb feat in rendering the elevation of its place in history.

And in an unprecedented happening, a PBS aired a Frontline-type Special about the making of this Episode. Entitled "ANATOMY OF A 'HOMICIDE: Life On The Street'"(1998). In it the origin of the story is revealed, as well as the collaborative steps involved in rendering the finished Episode from idea, story, script to Writer (and re-write) , Producer, Director and finally to the Actors.

The Special Documentary was 2 Hours in length and had the whole Episode of"Subway" to view at the end of the background material.

And Our Hats Off and a Great Big THANK YOU to David Simon, Paul Anttanasio,Barry Levinson and the rest of the Production Team and the Cast of "HOMICIDE", especially Andre Braugher, Kyle Secor and Special Guest Star, Vincent D'Onofrio for turning in a truly once in a lifetime Great Film, be it TV or Theatrical.
31 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
CLASSIC episode
CurtisJohn4 January 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Among the many noteworthy episodes on a show that's arguably the best cop drama of all time, is the Season 6 episode "The Subway". Vincent D'onofrio guest stars as a ordinary man who gets pushed down as he's exiting the subway car...and the train pulls off with him stuck in between. The worst part is - he's still alive and fully conscious, his body twisted below the platform.

The detectives have to determine how best to deal with the situation, as well as finding the main culprit.

This is D'onofrio at his pre-L&O:CI best.

Not to get too personal, but the writing on "Homicide" and this particular episode is a big part in what motivated me to work in film and television.
21 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Heartbreaking, Disturbing, Excellent Performances
sheezhank212 January 2007
Warning: Spoilers
If I weren't such a D'Onofrio fan, I would never have put myself through the discomfort of watching this episode. But Vincent didn't disappoint...he was awesome. Still, the episode, with its "implied gore" similar to the film Saw, was very disturbing. The plot line entails John Lange, a salesman, becoming pinned between the subway platform and the train. From the onset, the medic (whose bedside manner was about two degrees chillier than a Fudgsicle), makes it plain that Lange is a goner. So Braugher's character dispatches two not-so-motivated cops to find Lange's jogger girlfriend. I would have been sated, as would the D'Onofrio character, if he'd have had Sarah, a priest and a fat, greasy cheeseburger before the closing credits, but it wasn't in the script. Overall, though, good writing and expected great performances by the dependable D'Onofrio and Braugher made it worth watching.
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Superb writing, acting, directing and everything else
pvbklyn22 October 2011
I remember seeing this episode when it first aired. I thought this was a very fine series, but this episode stuck in my head for years. And when I watched it again a couple of weeks ago, this time uninterrupted by commercials, I was still stunned and had to look at a blank wall for a bit. This episode has to be the finest work ever done on Network television. It rises way above entertainment and leaves one speechless and pondering how fragile life can be. And it just doesn't go away. Whether you like that kind of thing or not, I know I do. It's a credit to everyone who was involved with this show. "Homicide: Life on the Streets" raised the bar for police dramas to an unattainable height for others in its wake. You can say that "The Wire" surpassed this series, but it could be debatable only because the focus in The Wire was not just the police but was far more diverse and gave us a clearer picture of society.
27 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Powerful....Gut Wrenching
sha-466 May 2021
I watched this series when it originally aired and was always impressed. However, this particular episode was totally riveting. I have never forgotten it.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the best singular episodes ever
schmenga11 October 2020
On any television show

Just spectacular for a one hour drama. No spoilers here, but D'Onofrio and all the regulars are superb and the established mood is both tragic and edifying.

MAYBE A SPOILER BUT I DO NOT THINK SO

When D'Onofrio delivers the line about the tree blossoms facing the sun that is arguably the best 5 second line in the history of television
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
James Yoshimura at his best
safenoe24 October 2016
Warning: Spoilers
It's not often an episode of a series gets over 250 votes, with a near 10 score. The Subway is one of them, and for good reason.

I'm a big fan of Homicide: Life on the Street, and The Subway is very haunting. It's supposedly based on a story from a passenger in Taxicab Confessions, and I really hope the passenger was just making it up.

In this episode Vincent D'Onofrio (excellent in The Player) plays a train passenger who has one of the worst days possible, being pushed into an oncoming subway train by some deranged guy.

James Yoshimura deserves much credit for this episode, being the writer. A PBS documentary charted the creative process of this episode, and is worth watching.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
It Was Andre Braugher..............
r-ellenh24 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
It was Andre Braugher who carried this episode. He was the one who sat with the dying man until emergency workers could free the man's body caught between the platform and the train. Braugher's character knew that freeing the man from between the platform and train would only cause the man's immediate death. Braugher played his part as if he were really sitting with a dying man, trying to help keep the man's spirit up while knowing he would die. It was when Braugher sat down on the platform and stayed there for the rest of the story that one felt that the story was real and not a TV episode. I give a 10+ to Braugher and to the creator of Homicide for producing some of the best TV in history.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Astonishing episode
mlbroberts14 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
A lot of others have said what I would have said, so I won't do a lot of repeating, but to say this episode stuck with me over the years is an understatement. Never, ever has there been a more powerful matching of actors in Andre Braugher and Vincent D'Onofrio in that subway, D'Onofrio trapped and only alive so long as he stays trapped because of the twisted nature of his injuries, and Braugher trying to comfort him, get the information to find out who pushed him, all the while knowing as soon as they get him out he will die. All ending with a last scene that bookends the first scene where D'Onofrio's wife went off for a jog, bidding him goodbye at the subway station.

The writing was as magnificent as the acting and as great as TV writing has ever been. This episode got Braugher his well deserved Emmy. Never has television been this good.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Vincent D'Onofrio is one of the greatest character actors ever!!
NYUndercover218 January 2007
Warning: Spoilers
I was never a fan of Homicide: Life on the Streets. Never watched one episode before last week. It was reported that "The Subway" episode would be aired on a relatively new channel called "Slueth" and it was just my good fortune to have The Subway aired twice in the same day!! I became a D'Onofrio fan over one year ago when I began to watch Law & Order:CI. And before that, I had seen Vincent in Men in Black. Naturally, I was curious when I discovered that he was portraying a New York Detective on a Law & Order show. This I had to see...and after watching just one episode, I was hooked.

I must admit, that Vincent's performance was nothing like his portrayal as Det. Bobby Goren and that was quite refreshing. Sometimes actors have problems developing and creating a whole new character for each movie or television appearance. There are no "cookie cutter" performances with Vincent D'Onofrio, his character portrayals are always fresh!!
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Stays with you LONG after you've sen it
KUAlum261 July 2008
When WGN America first(?) broadcast this rerun last year,it fell on Christmas. Having seen this first-run and wanting to have a HAPPY Yule,I wisely chose to not watch this then.

I saw it more recently,and I have to say that I was stoked to catch it again,and just like the first time I saw it,it hit me about as hard as any TV show episode has ever done. THe story is pretty well established by now,so I'll save the synapses and just say that the interplay between and among Detectives Pembleton,Bayliss,Falson,Lewis and a subway victim(Vincent D'Onofrio,who had just scored earlier that year with his yucky,Kansas farmer-turned giant bug habitat in the blockbuster Men in Black),who is still alive because the subway car has pinned him and therefore he is kept from "snapping" at the spine is some of the finest that's been on television,particularly on network.

The nearly poetic,thoughtful and soberly grim telling of this case is something that is difficult to forget,and indeed is a practical workshop in character study. If this won any Emmys,they were greatly deserving. A good ten years had passed since I first saw this,but seeing it again felt as clear as a bell. If I get these shows on DVD,I'd be stoked to see the extras surrounding these eps,and this one in particular would be worth examining.
20 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed