The final depicted is a merger of three finals - 1882, 1883 and 1884. The Old Etonians beat Sueter's Blackburn Rovers in 1882, and lost to a different Blackburn team in 1883 (that Sueter did not play for). Sueter finally lifted the cup in 1884... but his team beat Queen's Park in that final, not Old Etonians. Sueter never beat OEs in any final.