Rob Rosell, man. He is a damn treasure and this episode is such a fantastic example of it. I noticed his EP credit since the start of the season and wondered if he would be writing an episode as well, but it was a fleeting thought I hadn't returned to. It took less than 5 minutes into the episode to remember as I slowly fell into absolute awe of the writing prowess on display. *Every single line* was either hilarious, meaningful or crucial to the plot line. 0% fat. Like if skim milk was actually good.
Not to mention the character dynamics he fit into Gata's character all in one episode, starting with hilarious moment after hilarious moment (the entire Pledge of Allegiance scene, "I don't know I think she got cancer or something," "Ay Megabyte, where the bathroom at?") only to transition to the climax of the episode and one of the most revealing moments of his character to date *seamlessly.* He did that all while finding time to incorporate a tight setup to the episode's plot, Dave's S3 character arc, a hilarious Which is Worse: the Holocaust vs. Slavery debate, a concise introduction of 6 family members, callbacks to previous episodes of the series & a dual-purpose ending that pushes the character narrative of the season forward despite the episode's detour from its linear narrative. Oh, and as I mentioned, the episode was littered with joke after joke after joke, all of which landed. He's a master of his craft at this point.
I've watched Dave since it premiered, been blown away by multiple episodes (primarily in s2/s3), but this one? It sticks out like a sore thumb. I can't go without mentioning the PHENOMENAL direction by Shannon Murphy. I was on the edge of my seat, eyes glued to the screen from the very first scene. Her choice to set the tone how she did with that mesmerizing intro was brilliant. It paid off too, her ability to slowly increase the tension of this episode, scene-by-scene, then suddenly give us the ending's tonal shift without feeling abrupt or out-of-place... I was blown away.
So yeah, this is hands down the best episode of the series, and honestly, probably one of the best episodes of television in the past decade. The best way to describe it would be if you took the idiosyncrasies of peak Atlanta, combined it with the tightest writing from a Rosell-written Always Sunny episode & placed the cast of Dave right in the middle of it. A true 10/10 episode.
10 out of 13 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink