Sarajevo Roses (2016) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A Quarter of a Century in the making...
j-singleton22 May 2017
...Sarajevo Roses moves through the story of not only the city's siege but the entire labyrinth of the Bosnian crisis as if the film itself were being pursued by snipers. Director Roger Richards--a critically acclaimed AP photographer--created the film over almost a quarter of a century, and by doing so the story takes on an almost Opera-esque quality. Films done by photographers can get lost in the cloud sequences, so to speak, but Richards sprints us through alleys, under bridges and into bombed-out buildings in such a way that the poetry never replaces what was a horrific event--one that targeted anyone the Serbs caught in their cross-hairs.

Like Alice in Wonderland in reverse, Richards pops us out of those dark memories with sadly-beautiful stories of those who remain--survivors of an orphanage, a musician who once played for an audience of bullets, doctors who were then interns and finally, an impossible-to-forget sequence that will remain anonymous until you see it. It is impossible to call a film about genocide lyrical, but Richards has captured the resilience of a people who would not allow themselves to be extinguished. In Richards film their lives now mark one of the darkest moments of our time, like living imprints of the "Sarajevo Roses" for which the film is named.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Viewing the world through different eyes
helenepawlikowski4 June 2017
This is a poignant, haunting, beautiful, traumatic film. I barely breathed. At the end, I exhaled and wanted to weep and the tears are right there, quivering on the edges of my eyelashes. Why does this film mean so much to me, and why did it touch me so much? I have family members who live in Sarajevo, who are there trying to help. Actually my only grandson was born there. My husband and I have visited Sarajevo, such a beautiful city stained with red roses, memorials and a haunting sadness. I drank the water at the fountain so I expect to go back. I would like to return and I know I will view it through different eyes after seeing this skillful film. The threads of quotes, music, and stories bound the experience eloquently. Bravo and may we all learn the lesson. Love trumps hate.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Helping to heal a city's wounds
Normally, as part of any movie analysis, I would describe a scene that exemplifies the message and feel of a film. But in this case I will make an exception. My ideal scene was not the one I saw on the screen, but the one beside me. As I watched Sarajevo Roses I couldn't help but glance at a couple sitting nearby. Their sadness and tears as they observed each and every scene made me realize the effects on everyday citizens who survived the siege of Sarajevo and how the Sarajevo Roses can help this beautiful city heal its own wounds.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Lest we forget...
jozorados7 June 2017
It is incredible how easily one forgets the horrors of war. Therefore a remembrance and especially documented verity are precious. This film fulfils that role - and does it very well. I am a Member of the European Parliament representing Croatia. I watched the film at a screening the film-makers organised for us.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
What happens when a society implodes?
liuba-868379 June 2017
I saw this beautiful and poignant film at the Sarajevo Film Festival, where it created so much interest that an additional screening was organised. The five stories which take us through the course of the siege underline the message that such terrible things can indeed happen anywhere – under the appropriate conditions. A timely reminder.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
None as good as this one
I am a Member of the European Parliament and I watched the film at a special screening before the Parliament in December 2016. I personally lived in Sarajevo for a year during the siege. I've seen so many films about the war, and none has succeeded in describing the war experience as well as this one. If you want to know what it was really like to live in Sarajevo during the war, go and see this movie.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Searing documentary about the siege of Sarajevo
lefanumark8 August 2017
SARAJEVO ROSES

The terrible siege of Sarajevo lasted the best part of four years, from April 1992 to March 1996 and is calculated to have resulted in 5434 civilian deaths. An American photo- journalist, Roger M. Richards, arrived in the city early on in the conflict equipped with a pair of cameras and 30 reels of film, and stayed for the duration of the war, in the course of which he recorded many iconic images.

Now he has returned to the spot to make a documentary about the siege, seen through the eyes of three principle witnesses: a surgeon-turned-psychiatrist called Asim Haracic; an immensely engaging musician named Vedran Smailovic; and a bank worker, Sanda Skrabic, who was the subject of one of Richards's celebrated photographs of the time – snapped in color and in mid-air stride (so to speak) as she leaps forward towards the camera, valiantly dodging snipers' bullets.

The quality of the documentary is intimately linked to the articulacy and thoughtfulness of these very well-chosen talking heads. All three are amazing personalities. Haracic, the doctor, is serious, kind and modest. He has wise words to say about the depth of the trauma suffered by the city's inhabitants, and about how art-based therapy (he is an artist himself) can slowly bring healing. An inspiring humanist, in short. So is his colleague, Smailovic, the musician. An eyewitness to one of the conflict's first big civilian massacres (27 May 1992: twenty-two people killed by a single shell), he took his cello to the spot of the mass killing the next day, where he played, in mourning, an adagio by Albinoni . His friends urged him to repeat his performance the following day – and the day after that, and the day after that. His daily performances, lasting many months, became a symbol of the city's resistance. In September 1993 this man accepted an offer to leave Sarajevo - first to London, then to Northern Ireland (where he became a biker). Now he has come back to tell us what he remembers about the siege. The nightmare of that initial explosion still lives with him and has made him an ardent pacifist. "Believe me, walking on a street where blood has been spread is so much harder than walking on ice. Nothing in the world is more slippery!"

The third witness, Sanda Skrabic, received her fame only accidentally, you could say, through the wide dissemination of Richard's "road runner" photograph. Yet, having been tracked down by the filmmakers, she turns out to be just as engaging as the other two – just as brave, modest and eloquent. She reminisces about her happy middle-class childhood, and chides herself about being nostalgic for Tito's days. Her assessment of the hardship of the siege has not a shred of self-pity about it. And yet she is able to say about the whole experience in summary: "They {the besiegers} ruined the life I was supposed to have. What happened can never be erased."

Two other witnesses have smaller but equally affecting parts in the film: Amin Oprasic, and Sanela Tasic. Married now, they were orphaned street children at the time of the troubles, and they tell their story with simple unaffected dignity.

Films like this remind us how fragile are society's bonds, and how easily and carelessly civic life can become shattered. One moment, Sarajevo was a peaceful, prosperous provincial capital city, where different nationalities and religions lived together, in harmony; then, suddenly, almost for no reason at all, people found they were at war with each other.

An epilogue shows the recent peace-giving visit to Sarajevo of Pope Francis (June 2015); and the movie ends with a medley of children's voices, their young faces speaking directly to camera, sweetly telling us their hopes for the future.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Sobering "Must see" documentary
riprock900014 December 2019
My wife is from Slovenia. My memories of the Balkan war were the nightmarish scenes which were on the news and in newspapers. Her memories were of being on vacation with her parents at age 13 in Croatia when Slovenia declared independence. Slovenia was able to secure independence rather quickly while the remaining parts of Yugoslavia descended into war. I've visited Europe twice and in particular Slovenia. The war is still spoken about in mostly off hand terms. My understanding is Bosnia-Herzogovina is still very war scarred. The movie delves into the chaos of war in a modern atmosphere where many people never expected to be caught up in war zone. Given our current political atmosphere, I found myself a bit frightened. The people interviewed in the movie describe some very dire situations where innocent people were openly killed. I realized this could happen anywhere.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed