Let me be clear, I'm not a pretentious fop that wants movies to be 'exactly like the book'. I understand that's not possible. You couldn't have squeezed 800 pages of Wicked into a 2 hour play and you can't accurately put this book and its feeling into a movie.
That being said, the biggest problem with this movie is lack of substance at all. It's over 2 hours and about half of that are these dreamy, smeary, symbolic scenes. It's like Salvador Dali directed this movie. Wait, let me amend that to if Salvador Dali sucked and directed this movie.
Acting wise Stanley Tucci, Mark Wahlberg, are all outstanding. However, Mark's character is the only one we got to see develop. Lindsey's role was drastically reduced and Ruth (who was a VERY main character) is in this for about 2 minutes.
I was extremely disappointed. This was a complete waste on what was a phenomenal story, but just had little feeling on the big screen and was over the top on the symbolism and imagery. Okay, Mr. Jackson. WE GET IT. You have lots of vision.
As another reviewer said, if you have read the book, don't see the movie. My opinion is just don't see it at all!!
That being said, the biggest problem with this movie is lack of substance at all. It's over 2 hours and about half of that are these dreamy, smeary, symbolic scenes. It's like Salvador Dali directed this movie. Wait, let me amend that to if Salvador Dali sucked and directed this movie.
Acting wise Stanley Tucci, Mark Wahlberg, are all outstanding. However, Mark's character is the only one we got to see develop. Lindsey's role was drastically reduced and Ruth (who was a VERY main character) is in this for about 2 minutes.
I was extremely disappointed. This was a complete waste on what was a phenomenal story, but just had little feeling on the big screen and was over the top on the symbolism and imagery. Okay, Mr. Jackson. WE GET IT. You have lots of vision.
As another reviewer said, if you have read the book, don't see the movie. My opinion is just don't see it at all!!
Tell Your Friends