Change Your Image
natalia-malkovska
IMDb member since October 2013
Ratings
Most Recently Rated
Lists
An error has ocurred. Please try again
Fav Movies & TV Series of 2019
12 titles |
Public
Japanese movies & anime I've watched
194 titles |
Public
Movies that make me want to be a better person
90 titles |
Public
Poverty
10 titles |
Public
Psychological
118 titles |
Public
Saddest stories
20 titles |
Public
Fav Movies & TV Series of 2022
8 titles |
Public
Watched in 2024
61 titles |
Public
Strong/Brave women
51 titles |
Public
Korean movies I've watched
172 titles |
Public
See more »
Reviews
Where the Crawdads Sing (2022)
Unbelievable events, wishful thinking, good depictions of trauma and poverty
1 June 2024 - 0 out of 1 users found this review helpful.
I haven't read the book so I am only reviewing the movie based on its own merits. I am rating it lower for the cliché twist at the end.
First, I would suggest a more believable sequence of events (though much less dramatic):
- Tate never came back to his home town. He made life for himself in the city. He rarely thought about his first love.
- Chase got drunk and fell from the tower.
- Kya spent the rest of her life alone in the marsh, mostly satisfied in the company of nature, plants and animals. She kept writing books and died in peace.
And now to the actual movie.
The good:
- The depiction of trauma, abandonment, isolation, and poverty. The parts of the movie showing Kya's childhood and relationship with her abusive father were really good.
- The characters of Mabel and Jumpin', as well as the lawyer Tom are well depicted and not entirely one-dimensional.
The bad:
- The twist reveal at the end was what I was fearing. It would be better if the ending was left open, leaving us wondering what had really happened to Chase. The complicated premeditated murder would require a criminal mastermind to pull it off, not a socially inept marsh girl. Just because you know and understand the predator's behaviour, doesn't automatically make you able to act as a predator.
- Both of Kya's lovers are stereotypically one-dimensional. What about almost everybody in the town bullying, spreading rumours and hating on an abandoned child? Are we supposed to find that normal and understandable for people living in the 60's?
- The cheesy love story with a conflict resolved in a wishful way.
The conflict: His dream was to leave the small town and she was not able to leave the marsh. So, he went on to pursue his dreams and abandoned her.
The solution: He came back, having realised that success and achievements didn't matter, as long as he was with her. Basically, he gave up on his dreams to stay with her. She took him back after he had abandoned her. And they lived happily ever after. How more wishful could it be?
As a side note, why is it not possible to write about balanced and healthy relationships where both parties support each other's dreams and compromise to stay together? I guess the drama will be missing.
See more▼See less▲