I watched the whole series in the course of a few weeks. What initially looked like a mash-up of Twin Peaks and Stranger Things, was revealed to be an original and intriguing mystery.
What convinced me is the consistency of the unfolding mystery and a surprising added depth of character, drama and tragedy enhanced by the time dimension.
Twin Peaks comparisons might be a little unfair, as it had that inimitable Lynch touch. Here the directing reminds me of a competently done German "krimi" TV, spiced with sci-fi and experiments in disjointed storytelling. Which is not a bad thing at all, it seems.
For a sci-fi aficionado, the time travel aspects are not that novel, but Dark insists on probing the chosen route further, and takes it to its fatalistic and even nihilistic conclusions.
Watching all the seasons and episodes in quick succession might not be the best idea. The soundscape, repeated phrases and monologues, and the formulaic inclusion of a "mood song" near the end of the episode, may begin to feel tiresome. The depth and intelligence of the series is in danger of being revealed as an illusion.
To me, the series peaks in "Ein unendlicher Kreis" near the end of the second season. A conclusion could then have been drawn out in the course of a few episodes. I felt the third season was essentially stalling the outcome and "filling gaps", and needlessly fragmentary compared to the first and second seasons.
Re-imagining elements from first season as a "teen goth romance" was not really that interesting, and the human drama was no longer as nuanced as in the previous seasons. This opinion may also been a result of watching the series too fast and eagerly. As the series eventually concluded, it worked well and the path to the end was neatly laid out.
I enjoyed this series greatly.
What convinced me is the consistency of the unfolding mystery and a surprising added depth of character, drama and tragedy enhanced by the time dimension.
Twin Peaks comparisons might be a little unfair, as it had that inimitable Lynch touch. Here the directing reminds me of a competently done German "krimi" TV, spiced with sci-fi and experiments in disjointed storytelling. Which is not a bad thing at all, it seems.
For a sci-fi aficionado, the time travel aspects are not that novel, but Dark insists on probing the chosen route further, and takes it to its fatalistic and even nihilistic conclusions.
Watching all the seasons and episodes in quick succession might not be the best idea. The soundscape, repeated phrases and monologues, and the formulaic inclusion of a "mood song" near the end of the episode, may begin to feel tiresome. The depth and intelligence of the series is in danger of being revealed as an illusion.
To me, the series peaks in "Ein unendlicher Kreis" near the end of the second season. A conclusion could then have been drawn out in the course of a few episodes. I felt the third season was essentially stalling the outcome and "filling gaps", and needlessly fragmentary compared to the first and second seasons.
Re-imagining elements from first season as a "teen goth romance" was not really that interesting, and the human drama was no longer as nuanced as in the previous seasons. This opinion may also been a result of watching the series too fast and eagerly. As the series eventually concluded, it worked well and the path to the end was neatly laid out.
I enjoyed this series greatly.
Tell Your Friends