As is expected, Capaldi was great in this episode. He got a lot of moments to shine in this episode (both serious and comedic) and I absolutely adored his chemistry with Ashildr/"Me". It was interesting seeing Capaldi get an episode without Clara for the most part and see him play off just the guest cast. It was still nice to see Clara make an appearance at the end of the episode. Speaking of Clara, I must admit that this season is really pushing forward the idea of Clara leaving. They've addressed the idea so much throughout the season thus far that it's becoming a bit tiresome. Don't get me wrong, I love the dialog and the scenes in question but it just seems like they're shoving this in our face WAY too much. We know Clara's leaving. You don't have to keep reminding us about it through not-so-subtle foreshadowing.
Maisie Williams got to shine so much in this episode. While I liked her in the previous episode, she didn't really feel different from any other guest actor. Here, we got to see her play a pained, complex character who's lived for eight centuries and has grown desensitized by her immortality. Her anger and pain felt very real and Williams played the part with masterful skill. I really liked how this episode explored the idea of immortality and what it would truly be like for an average human to experience. A scene that really stood out to me was "Me" talking about why she forgets details about her life. An infinite life with a mortal memory. That...actually makes a lot of sense; and it only makes the concept of immortality all the more tragic. It's understandable why the Doctor can remember so much given that he's a Time Lord but the average human brain probably doesn't have the strength nor the ability to remember so much. It was nice to see "Me's" excitement for life revived by the end and I have a feeling that this won't be the last we see of her this season. Her ominously smiling at Clara in the background of Clara's selfie seems to be a huge bit of foreshadowing for the character's return at some point. Since this season's arc seems to be revolving around the hybrid Davros spoke of, it's becoming very obvious that "Me" is shaping up to being that hybrid. Will she be an enemy for the Doctor to face or will she become a new ally? We could have a new recurring character on our hands. If this means more of Maisie Williams and this character on the show then I'm all for it!
The only other guest characters who stood out were Sam Swift and Leandro. Sam was likable and I enjoyed his banter with "Me" and the Doctor. I also liked how the second Mire chip was used to save his life and stop the oncoming invasion. Sam's immortality was left open for debate given the situation he was in but I wouldn't mind seeing him again if he appears alongside "Me" in a future episode. Leandro had an interesting design and some vague, intriguing origins but that's about it. He pretty much had a similar plan to the Geth with opening a portal and allowing his kind to invade Earth. Oddly enough, both his invasion and the Geth's invasion involved death. Coincidence? Well, this season has been doing well at subtlety celebrating New Who's 10th anniversary so maybe this is more than just a coincidence.
Other quick things to note. It appears the sonic sunglasses are here to stay. Sorry to all you naysayers but I'm enjoying them so...tough. I also really liked the Doctor mentioning Jack Harkness to "Me". I wonder if this is a hint for a return. Please? Can we see more Jack? Well we're getting more River Song at Christmas so anything's possible, I suppose.
Overall, I loved The Woman Who Lived. It had great character moments, explored some interesting concepts, fully embraced its 17th century atmosphere, and gave some intriguing set-up for the future.
Maisie Williams got to shine so much in this episode. While I liked her in the previous episode, she didn't really feel different from any other guest actor. Here, we got to see her play a pained, complex character who's lived for eight centuries and has grown desensitized by her immortality. Her anger and pain felt very real and Williams played the part with masterful skill. I really liked how this episode explored the idea of immortality and what it would truly be like for an average human to experience. A scene that really stood out to me was "Me" talking about why she forgets details about her life. An infinite life with a mortal memory. That...actually makes a lot of sense; and it only makes the concept of immortality all the more tragic. It's understandable why the Doctor can remember so much given that he's a Time Lord but the average human brain probably doesn't have the strength nor the ability to remember so much. It was nice to see "Me's" excitement for life revived by the end and I have a feeling that this won't be the last we see of her this season. Her ominously smiling at Clara in the background of Clara's selfie seems to be a huge bit of foreshadowing for the character's return at some point. Since this season's arc seems to be revolving around the hybrid Davros spoke of, it's becoming very obvious that "Me" is shaping up to being that hybrid. Will she be an enemy for the Doctor to face or will she become a new ally? We could have a new recurring character on our hands. If this means more of Maisie Williams and this character on the show then I'm all for it!
The only other guest characters who stood out were Sam Swift and Leandro. Sam was likable and I enjoyed his banter with "Me" and the Doctor. I also liked how the second Mire chip was used to save his life and stop the oncoming invasion. Sam's immortality was left open for debate given the situation he was in but I wouldn't mind seeing him again if he appears alongside "Me" in a future episode. Leandro had an interesting design and some vague, intriguing origins but that's about it. He pretty much had a similar plan to the Geth with opening a portal and allowing his kind to invade Earth. Oddly enough, both his invasion and the Geth's invasion involved death. Coincidence? Well, this season has been doing well at subtlety celebrating New Who's 10th anniversary so maybe this is more than just a coincidence.
Other quick things to note. It appears the sonic sunglasses are here to stay. Sorry to all you naysayers but I'm enjoying them so...tough. I also really liked the Doctor mentioning Jack Harkness to "Me". I wonder if this is a hint for a return. Please? Can we see more Jack? Well we're getting more River Song at Christmas so anything's possible, I suppose.
Overall, I loved The Woman Who Lived. It had great character moments, explored some interesting concepts, fully embraced its 17th century atmosphere, and gave some intriguing set-up for the future.
Tell Your Friends