So I walked out the cinema around 2/3rd through, unable to watch any more. I had seen the odd review, that was overwhelming positive for it. I watched the first one, it was okay but found it boring. Im a trekkie by nature so thought I would love anything sci-fi. I did notice that it's scheduled for a streaming / blu ray release in just three weeks time, essentially killing the cinema even more. In my screenings on opening week, with 241 ticket offers on, there were six people in the theatre. So how it has reported making so much money in just days of its release is "questionable".
But I went into this hoping I would like it. I didn't it. It was just so boring. Which is odd as there are action scenes, but none of it made any sense. I have not read the book but the rebels had around ten people in at the start, and I left when the main protagonist said he had 200. Even though most of them we saw die in the raids. Where did the extra people come from? Why were they joining when they were being killed off so often? None of this is explained.
There are plot holes galore, as though entire pages of the script were just emitted in editing. For example, Wonka (because I don't know his Dune characters name) was handed a backpack of food and a tent and sent to start walking across the dessert. The very next scene, Mary-Jane is sat at the top of a sand hill talking to him. The tent is never set up, no food eaten. He's just suddenly back at camp?!
There is a scene when all the guards have laser guns, and wasps with shields, but are all taken out by people with knives who can somehow see in a sandstorm and not be affected by it at the same time. It makes no sense.
Then we have the worm summoning ground-pumper. Why not use it on one of the convoys and just send a worm into it? Why risk people's lives when you have that technology? Or why not ride a worm into the convoy? And how do you get off the worm after you've finished with it? None of this is explained.
Then we have the "big" bad guy, who kills all his servants for fun. Yet more servants keep showing up? Why would anyone ever work for him? What does he do to earn his role?
Why does his nephew's fight scene turn the film to black and white? Its this a students arthouse film? It makes no sense! Not to mention the fight is pathetic. They have to drug his opponents, who have tiny daggers while he has two swords and a personal shield. And a bunch of security guards on standby as well. This is suppose to be entertainment?
You fill in the plot holes in your mind, while watching trying to make sense of the many pages omitted. Which I think is why all the other reviewers are praising the movie like its a masterpiece. But I need the story to take place on the screen, not in my mind.
I know I'm in the minority in my thinking on this film, and all my favourite Youtube reviewers are praising it. But I just had to come on here and give my thoughts to balance out all the positive. Also, it costs a lot of money to go to the cinema and walking out of a film is not fun. When it's due for streaming release in just a few more weeks, I think you would be better to wait until then and save yourself the money. It's defiantly a film you can watch while playing on your phone, as three hours of two teenagers talking and shots of sand, while a foghorn bursts in your ears is not for me at least.
But I went into this hoping I would like it. I didn't it. It was just so boring. Which is odd as there are action scenes, but none of it made any sense. I have not read the book but the rebels had around ten people in at the start, and I left when the main protagonist said he had 200. Even though most of them we saw die in the raids. Where did the extra people come from? Why were they joining when they were being killed off so often? None of this is explained.
There are plot holes galore, as though entire pages of the script were just emitted in editing. For example, Wonka (because I don't know his Dune characters name) was handed a backpack of food and a tent and sent to start walking across the dessert. The very next scene, Mary-Jane is sat at the top of a sand hill talking to him. The tent is never set up, no food eaten. He's just suddenly back at camp?!
There is a scene when all the guards have laser guns, and wasps with shields, but are all taken out by people with knives who can somehow see in a sandstorm and not be affected by it at the same time. It makes no sense.
Then we have the worm summoning ground-pumper. Why not use it on one of the convoys and just send a worm into it? Why risk people's lives when you have that technology? Or why not ride a worm into the convoy? And how do you get off the worm after you've finished with it? None of this is explained.
Then we have the "big" bad guy, who kills all his servants for fun. Yet more servants keep showing up? Why would anyone ever work for him? What does he do to earn his role?
Why does his nephew's fight scene turn the film to black and white? Its this a students arthouse film? It makes no sense! Not to mention the fight is pathetic. They have to drug his opponents, who have tiny daggers while he has two swords and a personal shield. And a bunch of security guards on standby as well. This is suppose to be entertainment?
You fill in the plot holes in your mind, while watching trying to make sense of the many pages omitted. Which I think is why all the other reviewers are praising the movie like its a masterpiece. But I need the story to take place on the screen, not in my mind.
I know I'm in the minority in my thinking on this film, and all my favourite Youtube reviewers are praising it. But I just had to come on here and give my thoughts to balance out all the positive. Also, it costs a lot of money to go to the cinema and walking out of a film is not fun. When it's due for streaming release in just a few more weeks, I think you would be better to wait until then and save yourself the money. It's defiantly a film you can watch while playing on your phone, as three hours of two teenagers talking and shots of sand, while a foghorn bursts in your ears is not for me at least.
Tell Your Friends