4/10
Robert Mitchum's breakthrough role
20 August 2018
Even though The Story of G.I. Joe isn't nearly the best war movie that came out of the 1940s, it's a pretty famous classic, and for a bit of a sad reason. It's based on the writings of Pulitzer Prize winning Ernie Pyle, and while he was available to consult during the filming, he was killed in action before the film's release. So, while Burgess Meredith acted out his experiences, everyone in the audience was constantly reminded that the real Ernie Pyle wasn't alive to see it.

Along the lines of The Dawn Patrol and All Quiet on the Western Front, this is realistic, sad look at what soldiers went through on the front lines. This is not a propaganda film that shows our boys on leave, falling in love, and making it home in time for Christmas. Lots of soldiers die, and tragedies, frustrations, and opposition are shown on the battlefield.

Also, although this is an ensemble piece, Robert Mitchum received an Oscar nomination for Best Supporting Actor. This was his only nomination throughout his entire career, and if you watch more of his movies, you'll wonder why his talent wasn't more recognized. If you're a fan, you can rent this depressing war movie to see his breakthrough performance; just don't expect to feel good about it.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed