Unfortunately, this is a very pale imitation of the highly charming, wonderful 1949 film directed by Alexander McKendrick. It isn't poorly made but it is totally lacking in zest or interest. The plot and screenplay is more or less the same as the McKendrick version but both the direction and acting are as flat as a pancake (despite the presence of well established character actors) - none match the superior talents of such as Basil Redford, Joan Greenwood, James Robertson Justice, Gordon Jackson, John Gregson and so on. What is more, the cinematography and crisp editing of the superior original put this version to shame. I suggest you simply don't bother.
Review of Whisky Galore
