Water Lilies (2007)
6/10
J'aime les pays ou ils marient les filles a 14 ans
12 April 2022
A fascinating and indiscreet look into a summer for 3 teen girls synchronizing with the world, discovering their sexual drives and staying afloat while doing silly things. "A la Rohmer" someone might think: I partly agree but this first feature by Sciamma, proves to be much more modern, interesting and unwilling to indulge in exhausting blabla.

Yet a direction with some flaws - mainly in terms of pace and scene delivery - and a script with a lot of weak points - among which some weird behaviour by the characters and a general lack of realism (e.g. A. Haenel's character is too "old", experienced and pretty to be spending her time with P. Acquart's character). While the stylish choice of having adolescents apparently living without parents and doing the hell they like (surprisingly without the involvement of alcohol or drugs) might not be a problem, lots of other things don't really add up (and they don't seem all meant to show a fantasy world seen from the unexperienced eyes of our protagonists).

Hard to pinpoint exactly what is wrong with the execution of the storyline, but something is defintely off. Pity, because lots of scenes are quite suggestive despite their apparent simplicity. Wisely the writer/director decided that the lenght of 80mins was fine: going further might have turned the already mostly uneventful plot into a chore.

Great acting by all the young actors, with an especially good job by all the 3 main actresses.

Very good music by de Laubier at his first major work in cinema.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed