Tulip (1998) Poster

(1998)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A beautiful poetic treatise about the thin string that binds all living things to each other.
MzFranny22 April 2000
I hope she can keep acting and directing. She's surely up to the task and could easily develop that visionary streak into a long career of unconventional and rare works of art. Her work has a rare kind of generosity and her timing is spot-on! Oy I'm kvell
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A man readjusts to life alone after his wife dies.
karlpeter26 January 2000
A man readjusts to life alone after 45 years of marriage. He also has to solve the problem of the family milch cow, Tulip, which refuses to allow itself to be milked. Until, that is, he visualizes his wife who was the one who used to milk Tulip.

Tulip is based on a real story told in Griffith's family, of her grandparents' generation. The film is a nostalgic look back at a disappearing way of life, one where people still felt some sense of responsibility for each other, set in the lush green Victorian (the Australian state, not the era) countryside.

Writer and director Griffiths evidently has further ambitions in both areas, and this multiple award-winning 15-minute short is a fine beginning to her reel.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A heartwarming story of coping with grief
whiteberry8819 April 2002
Rachel Griffiths writes and directs this award winning short film. A heartwarming story about coping with grief and cherishing the memory of those we've loved and lost. Although, only 15 minutes long, Griffiths manages to capture so much emotion and truth onto film in the short space of time. Bud Tingwell gives a touching performance as Will, a widower struggling to cope with his wife's death. Will is confronted by the harsh reality of loneliness and helplessness as he proceeds to take care of Ruth's pet cow, Tulip. The film displays the grief and responsibility one feels for those they have loved and lost. Good cinematography, great direction, and superbly acted. It will bring tears to all those who have lost a loved one, and survived.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Available on video, excellent dialogue
colins-14 March 2002
"Tulip" is on the "Australian All Shorts" video from "Tribe First Rites" showcasing the talents of first time directors.

I wish more scripts had such excellent dialogue.

I hope Rachel Griffiths has more stories to tell, she does it so well.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A mixture of memories, love and a jersey cow, what you get is not your average cup of tea.
lovely_lukeye7 July 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Many people know how it feels when a loved one is lost. The feelings of pain, grief and sorrow can be unbearable. However, sometimes it is the memories they leave behind that trigger the saddest emotions. This theme is superbly portrayed in the short film 'Tulip', directed by the award winning Australian actress, Rachel Griffths. Described as a movie 'as much about memories as it is about love', a string of sensitivity and sentimentality is expertly threaded into this triumphant 15 minute film.

'Tulip' is a beautifully wrought, touching and heart-warming story of a man's journey in coming to terms with the loss of his wife through the relationship he shares with a very special animal, 'Tulip'. The film opens with a rising dawn, the chirping of birds and a vast landscape, introducing the sense of rustic harmony present throughout the film. A soft music plays, marking the entrance of Ruth (Jean Bain). She wears a flowered dress and apron with a sun hat on her head. She gently pets Tulip, caressing her ears and patting her back. The furnishing of the house is impressive and the attention to detail is creditable (a vase of tulips can be seen on the bench), reflecting the peaceful rural community. Will (Charles 'Bud' Tingwell) greets Ruth as she is spooning the milk from the bucket. They pour the milk and coffee together, a sign of companionship and teamwork. Not a word is said but it is obvious that their relationship is close and affectionate; they paint a perfect picture of happiness.

Sadly, happiness doesn't last forever. The tragic passing of Ruth affects Will deeply. An effective scene of fading cars highlights Will's isolation and vulnerability at the end of the day of the funeral. Soon he sinks into depression and becomes oblivious to his surroundings when everything seems hopeless and lost. At Will's moment of despair, Tulip becomes the symbol of Ruth, the genuine connection Will has with his late wife. It was through Tulip that Will learns to cope with the absence of Ruth and overcome the heartrending feelings of loneliness.

Each of the characters is realistically and solidly portrayed, especially the part of Will. Charles 'Bud' Tingwell brings the character to life through personal investment. The recent loss of his own wife (Audrey Tingwell) is effectively reflected in his acting. Every sag of his shoulder and every frown on his brow make the viewer empathize strongly with the character. The character of Ruth is wonderfully carried out by Jean Bain. Although Ruth does not say a single word throughout the movie, her sweet personality and loving relationship with Will are obvious. Lois Ramsey and Kati Edwards give delightful performances in supporting roles as the friendly Margaret and Mary. They also add a subtle humor to the bittersweet story.

An anecdote from Griffths' childhood, the story of loss and discovery is remarkably captured in 'Tulip'. Beautifully shot and superbly acted, this film will surely make you misty eyed, triumphant or feel like drinking a cup of milk.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A man, his wife, and a cow
alanjj2 December 2003
Neat little movie about a man, his wife, and a cow named Tulip. When the wife dies, neither Tulip nor the man are happy at all. Then, the man makes a discovery.

This is beautifully shot in lush Australian landscapes, filled with sounds of nature, especially one recurring sound of nature that leads to the man's discovery. A warm comedic gem.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Interesting – but poor message to deliver
bob the moo18 May 2002
A man tries to come to terms with single life after many years of marriage. Some of his wife's friends look after his home for him – but his cow, Tulip, is mopey and refuses to be handled by anyone but the dead wife. However by making links to the past and keeping memories alive they both go on.

This is based on a true story apparently and as such it doesn't have a point – it's just a story. It is funny enough, but you can see the punchline coming. It is quite touching to see the impact the death has on husband and cow, but the way they deal with it is unhealthy. The film's `point' is one of not letting go of memories – this is true to a point, but here the character basically recreates hi dead wife to please his cow.

I saw another short in French (literally `Pieces of my wife') which went the other way – the man had to get away and lose everything or he would die too. Here the message is that the best way to cope with loss is to live with the ghosts of the dead. It makes this point with little conviction.

Despite this it is interesting and touching at times. As an old family story it is interesting but as a message or a story with a point – it is lacking and too wooly.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed