"Girl Meets World" Girl Meets Smackle (TV Episode 2014) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
With the topic of beauty being skin deep as the focus, you get an odd mix of Disney making fun of their brand of geeks and touching moments.
Amari-Sali14 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
After a short hiatus, I felt a little off when first watching the episode. If just because this is the sole series dealing with tweens I watch, and with me being damn near a decade off from being a tween, it takes a little while to remind myself what middle school was like. Of which, as I think for most people, while Girl Meets World at its core can be deeply relatable, either in retrospect or in terms of your current life, every time there is a Disney moment you get a quick reminder that you have long since outgrown where Maya and Riley are. Though, even with that said, as you watch the episode it seems those Disney moments have less and less of an effect on you and almost seem as natural as everything else.

Topic 1: Too Great a Precedent - Auggie

Auggie is having an existential crisis as Ava talks about him and her not being together forever. Something which hurts Auggie for with Cory and Topanga meeting so young, and still being together, he sees them as what he should be able to achieve. Though thanks to a combination of Farkle, Riley, and Maya, Auggie seems to calm down his belief that him and Ava, who both are only 5 and 6, if I recall right, need to be together forever. It would be cute though if they did stay together throughout the series' run.

Topic 2: The Superficial – Smackle (Cecelia Balagot), Maya, Riley, Farkle and Lucas

The heart of the episode deals with the topic of beauty and how it can change someone and give them access to things and people they desire. Take Smackle for instance. She is Farkle's arch nemesis due to her intelligence and debate skills, and while she sees her and Farkle as a good match, romantic wise, he doesn't show any signs of interest. So, she takes note of how he acts with Maya and Riley and asks to be made over like this is some teen rom-com. Which leads to Smackle revealing that partly her whole makeover was done for research, but through the makeover she, and we, also get to see, and be reminded of, how much appearance can change things for a person. Like with Smackle and Lucas. Despite how generally nice Lucas seems, he doesn't compliment her on her appearance until after her Riley/ Maya makeover. Then, when it comes to Lucas, the stereotypical nerds judge Lucas so much just because he has a jock appearance. Almost to the point that in a normal situation, you can see him perhaps being uncomfortable with the idea of joining a passively aggressive debate team and avoiding them all together.

Topic 3: What's Deep Inside - Smackle, Maya, Riley, Farkle and Lucas

But while there is a lot gone over when it comes to things dealing with how superficial things can affect a person internally, and opportunities they may have, there are also a lot of interesting things not directly focused on that I thought were interesting. Such as the idea of multiple intelligences. For while it is obvious that Farkle and Smackle are book smart, socially they are novices. Something shown in most of Farkle and Smackles interpersonal interactions, unless the moment calls for them to drop the Disney part of their persona and step into their Girl Meets World alter egos. Take for instance Smackle's awkward hugging of Riley in which she simply sticks her arms out, speaks about her emotions like a robot, and yet when she needs to switch into Girl Meets World mode, she can hug Riley without looking like an idiot and can properly convey her past and current feelings when it comes to being herself, beauty, and even how she feels about Farkle.

Though the show also exhibits multiple intelligences when it comes to Riley and Maya as well. For with Riley being emotionally intelligent, in terms of empathy and kindness, it gives you the sense that life isn't solely about being book smart. It is also about learning and understanding how to interact with people or, in Maya's case, learning how to deal with life and people who are different from you. Never mind surviving less than seemingly viable circumstances.

Leading to one last topic: Why does Farkle take to Maya and Riley over Smackle, at least in the beginning of the episode [1]? Well, with this topic comes the question if Farkle likes to be the book smart one of his relationship? For with him genuinely seeming to not notice how beautiful Riley and Maya is, it makes it seem that the main reason he may not have liked Smackle, or acted like he did, was because she could match him at the one thing he is good at: topics dealing with books, science, and what is essentially the core of his identity. Making it so that dating, and being with her, would mean possible feelings of inferiority. That is in comparison to Maya and Riley who may not match him when it comes to book smarts, but they have forms of intelligence he admires for he perhaps feels he can't achieve them. So rather than have his match, or someone just like him, he'd rather have someone who compliments him. Think of it like Bill Masters and Virginia's relationship on Masters of Sex. Farkle is like Bill, he is the technical one, and he needs/ wants a Maya or Riley who can be his Virginia. Someone who can show him how to interact, be personable, and will love him despite his eccentricities and faults.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Disney really need to stop sexualising kids
chunkylefunga20 January 2021
You know as I watch this series I begin to realise more and more what's wrong with this show compared to the far superior boy meets world.

And it's that in boy meets world the kids were kids.

This series constantly sexualises kids and it's just weird.

Kids don't need makeup, skimpy clothing, or high heels. Kids don't go to school like that and it's just bizarre that the show keeps dressing the girls up like they're 21 year old.

So the episode deals with the point about beauty vs what's in the inside. Fine, that's a valid debate but first look at the main kids in the series. You spend hours an them to look a certain way. It just seems very fake and unreal.

Just have kids being kids, that's the secret to a good school show.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
What is beauty, who decides, and is there an alternative?
Ddey6521 January 2016
Warning: Spoilers
***MINOR SPOILERS***

There was a scene from the 1996 female Cyrano de Bergerac remake known as "The Truth About Cats & Dogs," where Uma Thurman takes Janeane Garafolo out for a makeover to give her the look of the '90's, and she becomes so horrified by it she bursts into tears at a water fountain near the mall food court. I'm with her on this, but that's another story.

Cory tries to teach his class the meaning behind the Trojan Horse, by using a fake presents with disappointing surprises. Just after the opening theme we get a debate competition between John Quincy Adams Middle School, and some nearby prep school for genius kids named "Einstein Academy." A girl from that school named Isadora Smackle (Cecelia Balgot), who we saw in the episode "Girl Meets Popular," straight up trounces Farkle in the debate over whether school uniforms should be mandatory, and he's devastated. However she's also madly in love with him, but can't get him to reciprocate the affection. Noticing that he has a crush on Riley and Maya, she requests a makeover from them.

Meanwhile, Lucas wants to join the debate team too, although the other nerds reject him at first, convinced that he's too much of a pretty-boy/jock to have anything to do with them, but Farkle talks them into letting him in. Later they set Farkle up on a date with Smackle at "Svorski's Bakery," however he knows that her request for a makeover is an attempt to win an upcoming debate over whether or not beauty is skin deep. In spite of this, Smackle is still willing to discuss their makeover on her and can't seem to make heads or tails behind the existing beauty standards. "Four red nails and one blue one. I don't know why." When new debate team member Lucas Friar casually walks in, suddenly his arch-nemesis is on the verge of getting as hormonal as a fangirl for boybands, and he tries to use Lucas against Smackle. Both debate captains realize she is too distracted by the cute boy who just joined Farkle's team, but we may find out she's not as distracted as the nerds of John Quincy Adams hopes.

The B-story involves Auggie and his childhood crush on Ava Morgenstern. He barges into the Matthews apartment like a G-rated version of Marlon Brando in "A Streetcar Named Desire" and grieves over the fear that they may not be together forever. He seems to think that just because Cory and Topanga were childhood sweethearts, that he should have the same destiny, and is devastated when he realizes that may not happen. I don't know how many people can relate to that, but I can. I always thought that there should be a girl in my life that I should've known from childhood, officially dated when I was old enough to do so, and marry when I reach legal age. It never happened, but that doesn't mean there aren't real-life couples who grew up that way.

Either way, Smackle's impassioned speech recognizing how superficial our world is, and urging us to look beneath the surface is a decent message that few of us truly live by, and admittedly, I'm not that much of an exception. Finally, there's Farkle's reply to whether he would be in love with the two main characters of this show if they weren't attractive. It was sweet, it was heartwarming,... but it wasn't true. Riley and Maya are polar opposites, and Farkle knows this. So, while the previous user has an interesting theory, I'm still convinced his crush on the two of them is primarily over their appearance.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed